QuicksearchCategoriesSyndicate This Bloglinkscontact usCopyright© 2012 athleticwomen.com. All rights reserved.
|
Thursday, August 9. 2007Not enough respect for female superheroes
I've noticed that sexism in comics has been a frequent blog topic lately. And there are good reasons for why that is so.
For example, it's fairly easy to see that female superheroes don't get their due. They're rarely given the status and careful development that male superheroes receive, and depictions of them are often so absurd it would be impossible to think of them as formidable characters anyway. Female superheroes should be depicted appropriately. We instinctively equate muscles and physical stature with strength, because that's how things generally work in the real world. That is why Superman and like-powered male superheroes are almost always shown having powerful-looking physiques, even though few superheroes actually get their superstrength in the weight room. It's unfair and self-defeating to treat superstrong female characters so differently. Thus, for me, Alex Ross's version of Power Girl is a vast improvement over Michael Turner's (which is awful no matter how you dissect it). I'm looking at this from the perspective of Amazon feminism, so I'm most bothered by simplistic binary representations of gender and gender role stereotyping; but there are quite a few other concerns being expressed about the treatment of female characters in comics, and most are legitimate. However, I don't like to see feminism confused with prudery and sexual puritanism, as so often happens when topics such as this come up. Which is why C. L. Hanson's superbly written "Questioning Objectification" (and her follow-up here) is such an important contribution to the overall discussion. I heartily recommend it, especially to feminists. Trackbacks
It's time to pick a new Wonder Woman
That's right, it looks like Wonder Woman is finally going to make it to the big screen! It's long...
Weblog: Athletic Women Blog
Tracked: Sep 24, 10:25
"I'm Power Girl Dammit!!!"
A little gem with a professional look one doesn't often find on YouTube—beneath the gloss,...
Weblog: Athletic Women Blog
Tracked: Feb 19, 11:51 Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
As a long time comic fan, I would agree that in the past women have not been depicted approriately, and that the medium has a ways to go. (Turner's Powergirl is one of the worst cases of this.) I would argue however that the comics industry has made great strides to treat female heroes better. There are some great comics out there with some strong female characters in them--Wonder Woman is a great comic, Susan Storm of the Fantastic Four is a very strong character, the Justice League of America is led by Black Canary, perhaps one of DC's strongest women characters, the X-Men have had several very good female leaders in the recent past like Storm and Rogue and some of the best written, most loved female supporting characters like Kitty Pryde, and Birds of Prey features a team of very strong female characters; Oracle, the Huntress and others. So comicdom's depiction of the female is getting better. It must be accepted that comic books always have, and most likely always will be a predominantly male focused industry, and all men love to look at well drawn pretty girls, even very happily married fathers like me. I am just glad though that some of these beautiful female heroes are no longer just sidekicks and eye candy but have become heroes and leaders in their own right. Unfortunately a lot of comic fans out there do fit the geeky pervert stereotype we have been saddled with. One day when my wife was picking up comics for me(that's right, my wife, a beautiful 30 year old real woman, a professional, hard working mother of two young boys with a little girl on the way, buys comics for her 34 year old husband, and shockingly reads them herself) several of the store regulars were engrossed in a debate on which female characters would be the best date (Catwoman was too skanky and Wonder Woman too bossy they decided). And you should see the stares I've gotten when I have stopped by with both my wife and sister in law in tow. At any rate, it is up to this generation of comic fans to influence the next. My sons will be taught to view women approriately, by my wife, a working mother, and by their dad, a soon to be staying at home Mr. Mom and my daughter will be taught it's okay for girls to read comics and want to fly like Supergirl or be astronauts or be cowgirls, or get married, stayhome and have babies, if that is what THEY choose to do.
Thanks for leaving a comment, Tom! It's obvious that you love comics and care about how female superheroes are depicted in them. I of course hope you're right about the trend toward better treatment of female superheroes. And I even share your optimism, for a moment anyway, when I see things like the Alex Ross version of Power Girl.
|
MEET Athletic Women ~ athletic men too ~ Online dating for singles into muscle & fitness.
Join FREE! muscle-personals.com |




latest comments
Mon, 06.02.2012 22:11
It is absurd that women have t o be more covered up than men and that the skin of women is demonized. Women are [...]
Mon, 06.02.2012 22:07
I think it is wonderful that t here will be more women compet ing in the Olympics this year than ever before. Go [...]
Wed, 25.01.2012 03:54
its not even close you can arg ue that women are already the stronger and more dominant sex .the only question is lo [...]
Sun, 15.01.2012 17:11
so what do you think about thi s: http://crooklynscorner.com /2012/01/rousey-cyborgs-failed -drug-test-a-sign-of-weakness/